Follow us on Instagram for updates from Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo! Check out our delicious deli offerings, including fresh salads and hearty soup. Don't miss out! @ANGELASPROVISIONS

Angela's Provisions
Angela's Provisions

Sandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's Provisions

Sandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's ProvisionsSandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's ProvisionsSandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's Provisions
Order Online
more About us

By the beach in New Buffalo, MI, you can enjoy delicious offerings from Angela's Sandwich Shop, a popular deli known for its fresh salads and comforting soups.

Sandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's Provisions

Sandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's ProvisionsSandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's ProvisionsSandwiches in New Buffalo: Angela's Provisions
Order Online
more About us

By the beach in New Buffalo, MI, you can enjoy delicious offerings from Angela's Sandwich Shop, a popular deli known for its fresh salads and comforting soups.

Menu

Grab-and-Go or enjoy outside on our Garden Patio!

Breakfast

Stuffed Biscuits

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy a flaky, warm biscuit filled with your choice of delicious options: green onion, egg & cheddar; sausage, egg & cheddar; or bacon, egg & cheddar for just $6.00. Don't forget to check out our salads and soup for a complete meal!

Bacon and Cheddar Croissant

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy a toasty croissant loaded with egg, bacon, and cheddar for just $5.00. Don't forget to check out our deli items, salads, and soup!

Guyere and Leek Tart

Enjoy a warm egg pastry filled with Gruyere cheese and leeks at Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo for just $6.00, the perfect complement to our deli salads and soup.

Mini Egg Bites (2)

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, try our delicious stuffed sandwich filled with three gourmet cheeses, available for just $5.00. Don't forget to pair it with one of our fresh salads or a warm cup of soup from our deli!

Sweets

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy a warm slice of banana bread for just $3.00. You can also treat yourself to our delicious cinnamon roll, or choose from our raspberry or chocolate croissant for $3.50. Don't forget to check out our salads and soup selections while you're here at the deli!

Hot Coffee or Hot Tea

Enjoy a fresh-brewed medium roast coffee or a delightful English Breakfast/Honey Lemon Tea for just $3.25 at Angela's Sandwich Shop, your go-to deli in New Buffalo, where we also serve delicious salads and hearty soup.

Cold Sandwiches

House Made Chicken or Tuna Salad Sandwich

Enjoy a hearty helping of house-made roasted chicken or tuna salad, crafted with premium ingredients, served on a cornmeal dusted kaiser roll. Topped with crisp lettuce and marinated tomatoes, this delicious option is available for $12.75 at Angela's Sandwich Shop, the go-to deli in New Buffalo for fresh salads and soup.

Turkey and Havarti Sandwich

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, try our delicious roasted turkey breast with Havarti cheese on a club roll, topped with crisp lettuce and marinated tomatoes for just $12.75. Pair it with one of our fresh salads or a warm soup for a complete meal. Add bacon for just $1.00.

Italian Sub

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy a delicious sub roll filled with Genoa salami, spicy capicola, mortadella, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, baby arugula, marinated tomatoes, and a drizzle of oils for just $13.75. Don't forget to check out our deli selections, salads, and soup to complete your meal!

Muffaletta Sandwich

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy our delicious deli creation featuring sliced ham, capicola, Genoa salami, and provolone, topped with traditional olive spread on a fresh seeded roll. Perfect for sharing! Only $14.75. Don't forget to check out our salads and soup while you're here!

Roast Beef Sandwich

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, savor tender cuts of slow roasted beef topped with horseradish mayo, fried onion, crispy lettuce, and marinated tomatoes, all served on a club roll for just $12.75. Don't forget to complement your meal with our delicious salads or soup. You can also enhance your sandwich by adding crumbled blue cheese for $0.75 or provolone for $1.00.

Make it a combo $3.00

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, you can add chips or a side salad to your meal, along with a refreshing 16oz fountain drink featuring Coca Cola products, lemonade, or iced tea. Don’t forget to check out our delicious turtle brownies, gelato, jumbo cookies, and Italian ices for a sweet treat after enjoying our soups and salads!

Hot Sandwiches

Italian Beef

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, indulge in tender cuts of beef served in a rich, flavorful au jus gravy, topped with your choice of hot or mild giardiniera for just $13.50. Don't forget to explore our deli options, including fresh salads and comforting soup. For an extra treat, you can add Merkt's cheddar for $.50 or provolone for $1.00.

The Angela

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy our delicious thinly shaved ham and mortadella, toasted with Havarti cheese. This flavorful sub is topped with diced green peppers, onions, and tomatoes, all served on a fresh roll for just $13.50. Don't forget to check out our salads and soup while you're here!

Chicken Meatball Sub

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy our chicken meatballs infused with fresh garlic and herbs, simmered in rich marinara sauce, and generously piled on a sub roll for just $12.50. Don't forget to add provolone for only $1.00! Pair it with our delicious salads or a warm bowl of soup from our deli menu.

Italian Grinder

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, you can enjoy a delicious sub roll filled with salami, hot capicola, ham, mortadella, provolone, and baby arugula, all topped with Calabrese juice for just $13.50. Don't forget to check out our deli selections, including fresh salads and soup!

Pastrami Sandwich

At Angela's Sandwich Shop, enjoy our house-seasoned pastrami on toasted Michigan marble rye, topped with Havarti cheese, tangy coleslaw, and whole grain mustard for just $14.50. Don't forget to pair it with one of our delicious salads or a warm bowl of soup, perfect for a deli experience in New Buffalo.

Italian Veggie Sub

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, indulge in our delicious chickpea spread, marinated artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes, hearts of palm, fresh mozzarella, crispy onions, and roasted red peppers, all served on a toasty club roll for $13.75. Don't forget to try our salads and soup for a complete deli experience.

Jumbo Hot Dog - Chicago Style

At Angela's Sandwich Shop, enjoy our 1/4 LB “Thru the Garden” with relish, sport peppers, tomatoes, pickle, celery salt, and mustard for just $6.25. Complement your meal with a side of our delicious salads or a warm bowl of soup. For an extra treat, add Merkt's Cheddar for only $0.75. Visit us in New Buffalo for a great deli experience!

Make it a combo $3.00

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, you can add chips or a side salad to your meal, along with a refreshing 16oz fountain drink featuring Coca Cola products, lemonade, or iced tea. Don’t forget to check out our delicious turtle brownies, gelato, jumbo cookies, and Italian ices for a sweet treat after enjoying our soups and salads!

Custom Salads

Michigan Greens Salad with Chicken

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, try our delicious salad featuring diced chicken breast, grape tomatoes, shaved parmesan, candied roasted pecans, dried tart cherries, all drizzled with poppy seed dressing for just $14.75. Don't forget to check out our selection of soups as well!

Angela’s Chopped Salad

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy a delightful salad featuring diced chicken breast, crispy bacon, avocado, grape tomatoes, red onion, ditalini pasta, blue cheese crumbles, and Italian Parm dressing for just $14.75. Perfect for a light lunch alongside our homemade soup at the deli!

Classic Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine, croutons, grape tomatoes, and shaved parmesan – $8.00. Enjoy this delicious salad at Angela's Sandwich Shop, the best deli in New Buffalo. Add 4 oz diced chicken breast for just $4.00 and elevate your meal with our fresh salads or a warm soup.

Simple Salad

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy our local greens, tomatoes, and cucumbers for just $8.00. You can also add 4 oz of diced chicken breast, tuna salad, or chicken salad to your salads for an additional $4.00, or pair it with a warm soup from our deli.

Tomato, Basil and Mozzarella Salad

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy yellow and red grape tomatoes paired with fresh mozzarella, torn basil, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil. Perfect for a refreshing salad or a light meal, this delightful dish is available for just $8.00.

Soups

Soup of the Day

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy our delicious deli offerings: 8oz for $5.00 and 16oz for $7.00. Don't forget to check out our salads and soup while you're here!

Brisket Chili

Packed with flavor and perfect for a cozy day at Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo. Enjoy our delicious soups, available in 8oz for $6.00 and 16oz for $8.00. Don't forget to add sour cream and cheddar for just $.50, and check out our fresh salads while you're here!

Sides and Deli Salads

Lemon Orzo Feta Pasta Salad

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy our delicious pasta tossed with citrus-infused olive oil, feta, and kalamata olives. Perfect as a standalone dish or as a side with our fresh salads and hearty soup options. Available in 4oz for $2.50 or 8oz for $5.00.

Tuscan White Bean Arugula Salad

At Angela's Sandwich Shop, we offer a deli selection packed with flavor, featuring fresh oils and spices perfect for enhancing our salads and soup. Try our 4oz size for just $2.50 or our 16oz for $5.00, all available in New Buffalo.

Potato Salad or Cole Slaw

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, our deli offers 4oz salads or soup for just $2.00, and 8oz servings for $4.00.

Chips

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, you can enjoy a variety of deli potato chips in assorted flavors for just $2.00, perfect for pairing with our fresh salads and soup.

Kiddos

Chicken Tendies

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy three crispy, golden air-fried chicken fritters—crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside—served with a smoky-sweet BBQ sauce, all for just $6.75. Pair it with our delicious salads or a warm bowl of soup for a complete meal.

Mac and Cheese

Enjoy a hearty portion of Cavatelli pasta drenched in rich white cheddar sauce at Angela's Sandwich Shop, the go-to deli in New Buffalo. Perfect for pairing with our fresh salads or a warm bowl of soup. Small (8oz) $6.50 / Large (16oz) $12.50

Cheese Melt

At Angela's Sandwich Shop in New Buffalo, enjoy our open-faced Havarti and Merkt’s cheddar cheese toasted on a sliced sub roll for just $7.50. You can also add tomato and bacon for only $1.00. Don’t forget to check out our delicious salads and soup while you’re here!

Get a Hold of Us

Get a Hold of Us

Come Visit

Friends, locals, and visitors to New Buffalo, please stop by Angela's Sandwich Shop and say hello! We offer a delicious deli experience with a variety of salads and soup. Join us Tuesday to Saturday from 8-11:30 AM EST for breakfast and 11:30 AM-2:30 PM EST for lunch. Don't forget to follow us on IG @angelasprovisions for the latest menu offerings and updates!

ANGELA'S PROVISIONS

225 North Whittaker Street, New Buffalo, MI 49117, USA

(269) 231-5122 info@angelasprovisions.com

Connect with Us on Social

Copyright © 2025 Angela's Provisions - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept